TY - GEN
T1 - Assessing the Life Cycle Viability of Reactive Carbon Capture for Methanol Production using the PIVOT Framework
AU - Tan, Eric
PY - 2026
Y1 - 2026
N2 - Following Executive Order 14241, the Department of Energy has prioritized the revitalization of the domestic coal fleet, securing over 17 gigawatts (GW) of coal-powered electricity [1]. To further bolster American energy dominance and enhance the economic competitiveness of the U.S. coal industry, there is a strategic imperative to maximize the total value output of existing coal assets. This can be achieved through the valorization of carbon streams, transforming them from a byproduct into high-value industrial commodities. One potential promising approach is Reactive Carbon Capture (RCC). This study conducts process innovation and viability assessments of an emerging RCC pathway for converting carbon into methanol - a critical industrial chemical and strategic marine fuel. We develop and utilize the Process Innovation and Viability Objective Tool (PIVOT) to evaluate this pathway. PIVOT is a data-driven framework designed to "pivot" emerging technologies toward their most economically robust and operationally efficient configurations. Some of the PIVOT indicators are derived from standard LCA impact categories, providing a transparent accounting of resource intensity and operational durability without relying on conventional sustainability terminology. By transforming complex process data into objective indicators of viability, PIVOT provides a clear roadmap for industrial scaling. A core feature of the PIVOT framework is its integration of Multi-criteria Decision Analysis (MCDA) through a Total Utility approach. Unlike traditional models that rely on subjective weighting, this method utilizes the Marginal Rate of Substitution (MRS) between performance indicators to calculate total utility. This allows for a precise evaluation of process alternatives based on their contribution to resource security and technical excellence. This presentation will demonstrate the PIVOT methodology as applied to the RCC methanol pathway for a resilient American energy future. References: [1] The Department of Energy (January 15, 2026), "The Trump Administration Is Reaffirming Coal's Role in American Energy Dominance" Available at: https://www.energy.gov/articles/fact-sheet-department-energy-ending-war-beautiful-clean-coal.
AB - Following Executive Order 14241, the Department of Energy has prioritized the revitalization of the domestic coal fleet, securing over 17 gigawatts (GW) of coal-powered electricity [1]. To further bolster American energy dominance and enhance the economic competitiveness of the U.S. coal industry, there is a strategic imperative to maximize the total value output of existing coal assets. This can be achieved through the valorization of carbon streams, transforming them from a byproduct into high-value industrial commodities. One potential promising approach is Reactive Carbon Capture (RCC). This study conducts process innovation and viability assessments of an emerging RCC pathway for converting carbon into methanol - a critical industrial chemical and strategic marine fuel. We develop and utilize the Process Innovation and Viability Objective Tool (PIVOT) to evaluate this pathway. PIVOT is a data-driven framework designed to "pivot" emerging technologies toward their most economically robust and operationally efficient configurations. Some of the PIVOT indicators are derived from standard LCA impact categories, providing a transparent accounting of resource intensity and operational durability without relying on conventional sustainability terminology. By transforming complex process data into objective indicators of viability, PIVOT provides a clear roadmap for industrial scaling. A core feature of the PIVOT framework is its integration of Multi-criteria Decision Analysis (MCDA) through a Total Utility approach. Unlike traditional models that rely on subjective weighting, this method utilizes the Marginal Rate of Substitution (MRS) between performance indicators to calculate total utility. This allows for a precise evaluation of process alternatives based on their contribution to resource security and technical excellence. This presentation will demonstrate the PIVOT methodology as applied to the RCC methanol pathway for a resilient American energy future. References: [1] The Department of Energy (January 15, 2026), "The Trump Administration Is Reaffirming Coal's Role in American Energy Dominance" Available at: https://www.energy.gov/articles/fact-sheet-department-energy-ending-war-beautiful-clean-coal.
KW - American energy dominance
KW - conceptual process design
KW - flue gas CO2 valorization
KW - life cycle assessment (LCA)
KW - Process Innovation and Viability Objective Tool (PIVOT)
U2 - 10.66816/pr2512177
DO - 10.66816/pr2512177
M3 - Presentation
T3 - Presented at the ACLCA 2026 Conference, 14-17 September 2026, San Diego, California
ER -