A Mathematical Design Framework for Membrane Pre-Concentration in Energy-Efficient Recovery of Fermentation Products: Article No. 138875

Due to the dilute nature of products manufactured via fermentation and cell-free bioprocessing, dewatering is a common unit operation in downstream processing (DSP) for bioproduct recovery, but it is typically energy intensive. To improve DSP energy efficiency for bio-based small molecules, integrating high-pressure membrane pre-concentration is a promising process option. However, this approach is typically constrained by a tradeoff between concentration factor (CF) and product recovery (PR), namely increasing the CF typically results in greater product loss, and vice versa. Here we developed a model that enables process design guidelines to: (i) identify scenarios in which the additional energy consumption and product loss from membrane pre-concentration are justified for use in DSP, and (ii) determine the optimal CF that minimizes process specific energy consumption. We compared the energy consumption of high-pressure membrane-integrated processes to evaporation-only processes and applied the model to an experimental case study for the separation and purification of butyric acid from Clostridium tyrobutyricum fermentation using an in situ product recovery (ISPR) process. The model estimated that integrating a tangential-flow reverse osmosis (RO) pre-concentration unit could reduce process energy consumption up to 45%. The use of advanced membrane pre-concentration technologies, such as negative rejection membranes and organic solvent reverse osmosis (OSRO), have the potential to further reduce the overall process specific energy consumption up to 96%, projected based on modeling. Overall, membrane pre-concentration, especially when strategically integrated prior to an evaporation step with optimized process conditions, holds significant potential for improving DSP energy efficiency, particularly in applications requiring substantial solvent removal for product recovery from dilute mixtures.